A+ A A-

Intra-varietal variability in the ‘Chemlali’ variety cultivated in Southeastern Tunisia by ISSR and SSR markers

Download this file (JNS_AgriBiotech_Vol_25_8.pdf)Volume 25, Article 8[Volume 25, Article 8]624 kB

M. Ben Mohamed 1,2,3*a

S. Ben Ali 1,2,3a

F. Guasmi 1

T.Triki 1

N. Grati Kammoun 2

N. Kamel 1


1Institut de Régions Arides, Rte El Djorf Km 22.5, 4119, Mednine,

2 Institut de l'Olivier, Sfax BP 1087, 3000,

3 Faculté des Sciences de Bizerte 7021 Jarzouna- Tunisie.


Abstract - The olive tree (Olea europaea. L), is a characteristic species of the Mediterranean landscape, this species account numerous varieties that show a wide diversity in their morphology and phenology. The Tunisian olive heritage is also characterized by a rich variety dominated by the presence of two main varieties, Chemlali (Center and South) and Chétoui planted in the North of Tunisia. Various studies of the olive genetic diversity carried out in Tunisia based on molecular or biochemical markers have concerned mainly the different varieties grown in the North and Center of Tunisia. Some varieties have been initiated in the olive cultivated in the South that’s why it is necessary to study the different varieties of olive trees grown mainly in Tunisian south-eastern. This work is aimed to study the genetic variability of intra-varietal olive Chemlali variety collected from different regions of the tunisian south-east, based on molecular markers ISSR and SSR. The detected polymorphism rate is 48.74% and 44.44% respectively. These two markers were found to be very effective in the study of the genetic diversity of these different samples tested. The examination of the two dendrograms obtained with two molecular markers shows the tested samples made genetic affinity groups regardless of their geographic origin.


Keywords: Olea europaea, genetic diversity, molecular markers, ISSR, SSR.



  1. Introduction

Olive (Olea europaea L.) is one of the oldest cultivated plants and is an important oil producing crop in the Mediterranean Basin. Trees are extremely long-lived and tolerant to drought, salinity, and almost total neglect and have been reliable producers of food and oil for thousands of years. There are two forms: cultivated olive (var. europaea) is clonally propagated by cuttings and grafting, and wild olive or oleaster (var. sylvestris) is reproduced from seeds (Khadari et al. 2008). Archeological data suggest that cultivated olive was derived from oleasters through vegetative multiplication of individuals presenting interesting traits such as fruit size and oil content (Khadari et al. 2008). The olive tree is a species with a high degree of cross-pollination that leads to high levels of heterozygosity and genetic polymorphism (Angiolillo et al. 1999; Rallo et al. 2000). Over many centuries, most olive cultivars have been derived by random crosses or mutation. The majority of varieties are highly localized, but there are a few cultivars dispersed over widespread areas. The development of locally specific varietal populations was carried out by sexual reproduction, whereas other cultivars were established and maintained by vegetative means (Lumaret et al. 2004; Breton et al. 2006). Currently, there is much confusion in the identification of olive cultivars. Identification of cultivars is considered a major requirement because of the longevity of the crop and the need to improve efficiency in growing olives and extracting their oil. It is crucial that cultivars be identified using powerful techniques. In the past, olive cultivars were categorized by morphological traits, including tree, fruit, and leaf characteristics (Grati-Kamoun 1999), which are influenced by environmental factors. Reliance on phenotypic characters has possibly led to great confusion and uncertainty about the current classification of olive varieties in many countries. Recently, molecular techniques based on DNA markers have been shown to provide powerful tools for genetic analysis of olive cultivars (Belaj et al. 2001; Busconi et al. 2003; Pafundo et al. 2005). Among these markers, microsatellites (SSR) have become the most popular in many species (Qin et al. 2012; Guo et al. 2012), and in olive cultivars they have a high potential for resolving issues of synonymies, homonymies, and misnamings (Taamalli et al. 2006; Rekik et al. 2008; Muzzalupo et al. 2009).


2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Plant material

Molecular analysis was performed Twelve Tunisian olive accessions all belonging to the variety ‘Chemlali’, olive trees were selected from different geographical regions of the South-East Tunisian.


Figure 1. Map of geographic origin of accessions used in this study


The ‘Chemlali’ accessions analyzed and their origins are reported in Table 1.


Tableau 1. Studied accessions of olive genotypes and their origin


Denomination accessions in targeted locations


Geographic region of production origin

Denomination cultivars in targeted locations

Chemlali Abyath

South East


Chemlali Douiret

South East


Chemlali Ontha

South East


Chemlali Djerba

South East


Chemlali Zarzis

South East


Chemlali el Gorthab

South East


Chemlali Drina

South East


Chemlali –el Alea

South East


Chemlali Dakhla

South East


Chemlali IRA Médenine

South East


Chemlali Matmata

South East


Chemlali Ben Guerdane

South East

Ben Guerdane

2.2. DNA extraction

Total genomic DNA was extracted from young leaves using the CTAB method according to the protocol of Rekik et al. (2008). DNA so prepared was further purified and resuspended in Tris-EDTA of pH 8.0. The quantity of the DNA was as­sessed by and the quality by 2 % agarose gel electrophoresis.


2.3. Primers used

The same DNA samples analyzed by ISSR (A1, A2 and A3) were also analyzed using SSR markers. SSR analysis was performed according to Bornet and Branchard (2001) using 3 primers. These markers were selected for their high polymorphism in many olive cultivars (Lumaret et al. 2004) and in tunisian cultivars (Grati-Kamoun et al. 2006).


2.4. ISSR and SSR fingerprinting

Each PCR reaction is performed in a total volume of 25μl, containing 2μl of buffer (5x Colorless GoTaq Flexi Buffer) PCR, 2μl (100 ng) of genomic DNA, 25 mM MgCl2, and 500U of Taq polymerase. We varied the concentration of 2 mM to 4 mM NTP and the amount of primer 2 to 4μl and for a stock solution of 10 μM. Amplification was carried out using a thermocycler (DNA-Amp Master cycler gradient eppendorf). The initial denaturation was performed for 5 min at 94 ° C, followed by 45 cycles (1 min at 94 ° C, 45 sec at Tm (45°C) specific primer and 1 min 72°C) and followed by a final extension of 7 min at 72 ° C. For the SSR primer, the program: 95°C for 5 min for denaturation, followed by 40 cycles (30 sec at 94 ° C, 45 sec at 60 ° C and 1 min at 72 ° C) and followed by a final extension of 7 min at 72 ° C (Rekik 2008).


2.4. Data analysis

All analyses were carried out using the program MVSP version 3 (Multi Variate Statistical Package).

Polymorphic bands were recorded into a data matrix of presence (1) and absence (0) of bands. This data matrix obtained by scoring the ISSR and SSR profiles both individually as well as collectively were subjected to the calculation of a similarity matrix (S) using Jaccard’s coefficients (Jaccard, 1908). Several parameters were considered in this study: The polymorphic bands percentage (PBP), the resolving power (RP) was calculated for each primer according to Backus and Gilbert (1968): RP= ∑ Ib; Ib= 1-(2|0.5-p|); where p: is the proportion of species containing I bands. Genetic relationships among cultivars are represented by a dendrogram based on the distances calculated from the Jaccard index. The dendrogram was constructed using the Unweight Pair Group Method using an Arithmetic average (UPGMA).


3. Results

3.1. ISSR analysis

The analyses of the amplification profiles obtained for each primer are summarized in Table 2.


Tableau 2. Polymorphic bands percentage (PBP), the resolving power (RP) and Average informative bands (AVIb).


Bands ISSR

Resolving power (RP)


Average informative bands (AvIb)

Sizes of bands (PB)



% of polymorphism






























Three primers were able to generate 31 bands (15 polymorphic), with 48.74% polymorphism and an average of 5 polymorphic bands generated per primer. The size of bands varies between 150 and 900 bp. The percentage of polymorphism ranged from 41.66% to 54.55%. The primer ISSR1 revealed the lowest percentage (41.66%) while the primer ISSR3 detected the highest percentage (54.55%).

The three polymorphic primers also showed variations in the average of informative bands (AvIb) and the resolving power (RP). The average of AvIb ranged from 0.22 to 0.23. The primer ISSR2 showed the lowest value of AVIb (0.22) and also the lowest value of Rp (2.89) so that the primer ISSR3 has the highest value of Rp (3.56).

3.2. Patterns of genetic diversity based on ISSR

Each polymorphic band was recorded into a data matrix of presence (1) and absence (0) of band. This data matrix was converted into a Similarity matrix (S) using Jaccard coefficient (Jaccard, 1908), and the establishment of dendrogram (Figure 2) by unweighted pair group method using an arithmetic average cluster analysis. The similarity degree between the 12 olive accessions based on ISSR markers ranged from 0 to 0.882. This result shows the high degree of intervarietal genetic diversity at ‘Chemlali’ variety. The smallest genetic distance value of 0.2 was observed between ' Chemlali Djerba' and 'Chemlali Douiret' as well as 'Chemlali Dakhla' and 'Chemlali-el Alea'. The maximum genetic distance (Dg>0.8) was found between different combinations:


-'Chemlali Matmata' and 'Chemlali Abyath'; 'Chemlali Ben Guerdane' and 'Chemlali Zarzis'; 'Chemlali IRA Médenine' and ‘Chemlali Abyath' (dg = 0.867).

-'Chemlali Ben Guerdane' and 'Chemlali el Gorthab'(dg = 0.882).

- 'Chemlali el Gorthab' and 'Chemlali Zarzis'(dg = 0.875).

-'Chemlali Ben Guerdane' and 'Chemlali Douiret'; 'Chemlali IRA Médenine' with 'Chemlali Ontha' and 'Chemlali el Gorthab' (dg = 0.857).


It should be noted that 'Chemlali IRA Médenine' has the largest genetic distances with relatively all accessions.

The (S) matrix of ISSR markers allowed the distinction of the 12 tunisian olive accessions and was used to generate a dendrogram (Figure 2). The dendrogram depicts the pattern of relationships between the studied accessions. There is no clear clustering of accessions in relation with their growing area. Nevertheless, four clusters can be defined.


* Group1 formed by 10 accessions «Chemlali Abyath, Chemlali el Alea, Chemlali Douiret, Chemlali Ontha, Chemlali Drina, Chemlali Djerba, Chemlali Zarzis, Chemlali Dakhla» from Mareth-Gabès, Tataouine , Djerba, Zarzis and Médenine respectively.

* Group2 contains only «Chemlali el Gordab» from Tataouine.

* Group3 includes two accessions «Chemlali Matmata» and « Chemlali Ben Guerdane ».

* Group4 contains only «Chemlali IRA Medenine» characterized by high genetic distance with the rest of studied accessions (0.687 and 0.846).


Figure 2. Dendogram of 12 olive cultivars generated by UPGMA cluster analysis of the genetic similarity values using ISSR data.


3.3. SSR analysis

The analyses of the amplification profiles obtained for each primer are summarized in Table 3.


Table 3. Polymorphic bands percentage (PBP), the resolving power (RP) and Average informative bands (AVIb).


SSR Bands

Resolving power (RP)

Average informative bands (AvIb)

Sizes of bands (PB)



% of polymorphism






























Seven different bands were obtained using 3 primers from which 4 were polymorphic with 44.44% polymorphism rate. The molecular size of obtained bands ranged from 150 to 700 bp. The primers OUB.2 and GAPU.47 showed 2 polymorphic bands while UDO.004 showed a monomorphic pattern.

The average AvIb ranged from 0.3 to 0.83 while Rp ranged from 0.91 to 1.66 (Table3). The primer UDO.004 showed the lowest AvIb value (0.3) and the lowest Rp (0.91), while the highest AvIb value (0.83) and the highest Rp (1.66) are showed at the primer GAPU.47.

The genetic similarity values based on Jaccard’s coefficient ranged from 0 between 'Chemlali Ben Guerdane' and 'Chemlali el Gorthab' ; 'Chemlali el Alea' , 'Chemlali IRA Médenine' and 'Chemlali Matmata' to à 1 between 'Chemlali Dakhla' and 'Chemlali Djerba'.


Figure 3. Dendogram of 12 olive cultivars generated by UPGMA cluster analysis of the genetic similarity values using SSR data


Affinities among cultivars and accessions are shown in the dendrogram (Figure 3), forming three groups. The first group represented by 10 accessions «Chemlali Abyath, Chemlali Douiret, Chemlali Ontha, Chemlali Djerba, Chemlali Zarzis, Chemlali el Gorthab,Chemlali Drina, C